I wasn’t sure about size based on other reviews. I wear between a 10 and 11 depending on boot. I went with a 10 since there are no 1/2 sizes. The 10 fit perfect and I have room for winter socks(I live in Minnesota.). So far, they have had good traction with the winter weather we’ve received. They are 100% better than my Docs are in the MN winter. They were also comfortable out of the box. The leather was a bit stiff, but that’s to be expected. I’ve worn them daily since they came, and they’ve broken in nicely. I have had no issues on any long walks with comfort. They came faster then the shipping window too - about a day. All in all, so far, they seem to be a good investment for daily wear winter boots.